Smoked Jalapeño Poppers with Smoked Bacon. An easy game day appetizer perfect for Super Bowl made with crispy smoked bacon, cream cheese and cheddar cheese.
But because Super Bowl is coming up, we’re adding these to the roster of game day party food!
If there is ever a season for awesome bites it’s the late winter and early spring. Between the football playoffs and March Madness, having friends over and wowing them with some delicious finger foods cooked on the smoker is always a treat.
This is so easy to make yet seems to intimidate so many people we talk to. My take on the classic popper is to deconstruct it a little. A lot of folks will stuff the jalapeños with dense cream cheese and wrap in bacon or deep fry. For me, I like the flavor of the jalapeño pepper to stand out balanced with some crunchy bacon and creamy cheese.
So instead of deep frying or wrapping in bacon, I cut the jalapeños in half and then stuff with a mixture that includes diced crispy smoked bacon and creamy cheeses. Then I smoke them for a nice rich and delicious jalapeño popper. You can grill it too or even roast in the oven, but if you have a smoker, you’d be silly to not take advantage of what awesomeness will come about.
If you smoke the jalapeño poppers, watch out for a couple things:
1) Many jalapeño popper recipes cooked on the smoker call for wrapping a whole piece of bacon around the jalapeño. Now I love me some bacon just like the next guy (unless that guy next to me is a vegetarian), but what I’m not a fan of is soggy bacon. We’ve found when we do it that way the bacon doesn’t crisp up enough for my taste, but rather steams in the smoker never getting that crunchy exterior. It gets soft and sometimes soggy rather than crispy. So we smoke the bacon first, to get it nice and crispy, and then dice it up and add it to the cheese mixture. On the flip side, if you go longer or higher heat and try to crisp the bacon, you can run the risk at overcooking the pepper or drying out the cheese making for a not so pleasant texture.
2) For a creamy filling we like to whip the already softened cream cheese a bit, and then mix in some smoked cheddar (regular sharp cheddar also works just fine). This helps for the filling to be creamy instead of dense. Recipes that call for just cream cheese (not whipped) tend to come out a little dense when slow cooked on the smoker. Not a fan. This way, you get everything — crispy bacon and a creamy filling.
You’re almost ready for the game!
Add some cheesy dips to the mix and it’s on. Try this beer cheese dip with smoked sausage for a nice accompaniment. And if you ask my wife about a wine pairing? Sparkling wine would be her go-to. Shocker.
Some more game day food suggestions:
- Grilled Jalapeño Poppers
- Brisket Chili
- The Ultimate Smoked Buffalo Chicken Wings
- Smoked Buffalo Chicken Dip
- Pork Belly Burnt Ends
- Smoked Stuffed Meatballs
- 4 slices of thick cut bacon (yields approx 1/3 cup when cooked and diced up)
- 10 medium sized jalapeño peppers
- 1 cup smoked cheddar cheese shredded
- 4 ounces softened cream cheese whipped
- Garnish can use green onion, Italian parsley, etc
Preheat smoker to 250 degrees and place bacon on smoker for about one hour or until crispy.
While bacon smoking; cut the stems off the jalapeño and then cut in half lengthwise. Remove ribs and seeds (that’s where a lot of the heat comes from).
Arrange on a sheet tray or cookie drying rack.
While waiting for the bacon, whip your cream cheese, either with a fork whisking quickly, or use a mixer at high speed for just a few seconds.
When bacon is crispy, remove from smoker and finely chop, then add to a bowl. Add remainder of ingredients to the bowl and mix together. If you want more creaminess add more whipped cream cheese.
Fill each jalapeño with about 1 tablespoon of the mixture; it should be lightly packed with a slight rise to the mixture (see photo above).
Place on smoker at 250 degrees for 30 – 45 minutes. You are looking for the cheese to melt and the jalapenos to look slightly roasted. Remove and serve.
You can prepare everything in advance until it's time to smoke the poppers. Just stuff the jalapeños and put in fridge in batches and just keep them added to the smoker throughout the game so that each batch is warm and fresh. Awesome finger food.
Wine or Beer Pairing?
It’s Game Day, so you may be thinking, silly Mary, this is beer holiday! Well you can go ahead and drink your beer if you wish (I think a crisp pilsner tastes awesome with these poppers), or you can take my advice and drink bubbles. Spanish Cava works wonders with these poppers. They tend to have bolder flavors that can stand up to the smoky bacon and the powerful bubbles can cut through the creamy cheese the same way a beer would.
Poema Brut Cava from Penedes Spain is a great option. It’s affordable at around $12, and is nice and tangy with green apple, fresh pears, and bright citrus. This wine is bold and zesty and stands up like a champ to these poppers and will stand up equally well to whatever else you serve on Super Bowl Sunday. (media sample)
What’s your plan for for Super Bowl?
If you like this recipe we’d truly appreciate it if you would give this recipe a star review! And if you share any of your pics on Instagram use the hashtag #vindulge. We LOVE to see it when you cook our recipes.